Skip to content

Fighting the Battle On All Fronts

Screenshot

Lyda becomes a Lawyer 

Lyda Conley (1869–1946)
Born in 1869, Eliza “Lyda” Burton Conley was the youngest of four daughters—a child of broken treaties and braided lineage. Her mother, Eliza Burton Zane, was Wyandot, and the great-granddaughter of Chief Tarhe. Her father, Andrew Syrenus Conley was a Scottish-American farmer. Lyda came into the world on contested ground, shaped by forced removal, tribal fracture, and too many legal betrayals.

In the Treaty of 1855, fourteen years before Lyda’s birth, her mother received a land allotment from the Wyandot reservation—part of the federal scheme to dissolve tribal communal lands. With Kansas statehood looming, American settlers squatted on reservations and demanded removals, creating deep suffering and confusion for many Kansas tribes. Though the treaty said Wyandot allotments could not be taxed for five years after statehood, this was also disregarded and many Wyandots lost their land for “unpaid taxes.”

In 1860, Eliza married Andrew Conley, and together they began farming her allotment near the Missouri River.  They were poor, but determined to thrive. After four girls were born within 10 years, they knew they wanted all their daughters to be well read, well spoken, and fiercely informed. Books filled their home. Learning was not a luxury—it was survival.  But the Missouri river rose and washed their farm away—taking their livelihood with it. The family was left destitute.

Lyda’s formative years were shaped as much by loss as by learning. Between the ages of ten and twenty, she endured many deaths: mother, oldest sister, grandmother, father. One by one, they were buried in the Huron Indian Cemetery (known today as the Wyandotte National Burying Ground). Grief became the landscape of her young adulthood.

And still—Lyda heard her parents’ word: Education.

She enrolled at Park College in Parkville, Missouri. She taught at Spaulding Business School in Kansas City, Missouri, along with Sunday School at her family’s church. When the Conley Sisters learned about the pending sale of the Huron Indian Cemetery, their sacred burial grounds, Lyda jumped into law school—graduating from Kansas City School of Law in 1902. She studied the very systems designed to erase her people and learned how to fight court battles. Lyda stood with clarity, resolve, and a purpose rooted in Wyandot culture, community, and family.

Lyda in the Courts

Lyda Conley always knew that protecting the Huron Indian Cemetery would take more than protest—it would take the legal system.

In 1906, Congress approved a bill to sell the cemetery land. Immediately Lyda filed for an injunction in U.S. District Court against the Secretary of the Interior and Indian Commissioners. She lost—but refused to give up. Immediately she filed an injunction, and waited for word from the U.S. Supreme Court. During that wait she and her sisters launched their physical fight and built Fort Conley, creating a story that traveled the world.

In January 1910, Lyda and Sister Lena arrived in Washington, D.C. No local lawyers agreed to sponsor her bar admission, so the Court allowed her to appear pro se—representing herself. On January 14, 1910, Eliza “Lyda” Burton Conley became the first Native woman, and only the third woman ever, to argue before the U.S. Supreme Court.

She spoke with fiery passion about how the 1855 Treaty made promises to protect the sacred Wyandot burial ground. But Court Justices unanimously ruled against her. The U.S. no longer recognized Wyandots in Kansas. The cemetery was legally owned by their Wyandotte relatives in Oklahoma. So the court claimed she lacked legal standing. 

Later Chief Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes contacted Lyda to echo the Court’s deep sympathy for her cause, acknowledging the law was not on her side. U.S. policies had divided the Wyandot peoples, split up families, and refused to enforce the Treaty of 1855 that said “The portion now enclosed and used as a public burying-ground, shall be permanently reserved and appropriated for that purpose.” They blocked the path to protect this tiny plot of sacred and sovereign land.

Back in Kansas City, the Conley Sisters kept fighting. They posted more signs, locked more gates, and rebuilt Fort Conley every time it was torn down. Armed with determination, curses, and one old shotgun, they chased away trespassers. Reporters came. Supporters rallied.

Then Kansas’ own U.S. Senator Charles Curtis–of Kaw Nation descent–took notice. He introduced legislation to stop the sale and provide federal support for the cemetery. The bill passed. 

The Conley Sisters had won a critical victory, but the battle wasn’t over yet.

While dust settled and unsettled again about the cemetery’s future, Lyda lived a life of service. Most of her legal work focused on helping other Wyandots with routine legal matters and advocating for incarcerated Native men. In 1915, Eliza Burton Conley was admitted to the Supreme Court Bar. 

Although she lost her 1910 Supreme Court case, Conley’s defiance drew the attention needed to protect the cemetery. As the first Native woman to argue in front of the country’s highest court, she pioneered Native activism and law that define tribal nation rights to the present.  Today, she is widely recognized as an inspiration to Native attorneys, who fight for sovereignty, cultural preservation, and legal recognition.

Becoming a Historic Landmark  

The Conley Sisters still feared intruders would ignore court orders. So they kept up their vigil—blocking city work crews and vexing public officials for decades. In 1937 Lyda was arrested for nuisance and trespass. Given a choice of a $10 fine or ten days in jail, she chose jail. “While we live,” she vowed, “these bodies shall not be disturbed!”

One evening in 1946, as Lyda walked home from the library, a robber struck her with a brick and stole her purse—only twenty cents inside. She died the next day from head injuries. Hundreds gathered when she was laid to rest beside her parents, her grave marked by a granite stone, fit for a chief.

Still, developers persisted—promoting parks, parking lots, even skyscrapers to replace the cemetery.  But generations of Wyandot, Wyandotte, and Wendat voices, joined by scholars and Native rights allies, refused to yield. They continued to speak up for this sacred ground. In the 1950s, a young Wyandot girl walked the quiet graves with her grandmother. Birds sang. Leaves rustled. Then, three teenage boys ran by. One waved a metal sign, laughing. “Come back here!” Grandmother cried. One boy paused. “Scavenger hunt,” he shrugged, embarrassed, but ran on. Tears streamed down the grandmother’s face. “That little metal sign,” she said, “marked my baby son’s grave.” They walked on in silence, past great-grandmothers and grandchildren—an unbroken line of loss and memory.

In 1998 the cemetery joined the National Register of Historic Places. The Wyandotte Nation of Oklahoma, the legal owner of the cemetery, worked with the Wyandot Nation of Kansas to declare the land sacred—reserved for Tribal burials, ceremonies, and gatherings honoring the Wandat Diaspora.

In 2016, after a century of protest and prayer, the US Dept of the Interior named it the “Wyandotte National Burying Ground,” a National Historic Landmark.

Kaw homeland, taken by the U.S. government to become a Delaware reservation. Then,  gifted by the Lenape in a time of crisis, the site is sometimes forgotten amid urban bustle. Yet the Wyandotte National Burying Ground—once the Huron Indian Cemetery—still rises, asking for respect, attention, and renewed commitment. A monument to solace. To sovereignty. To the circle unbroken.